I DID IT!
I actually sat down and followed some of Natalie Norton's tips and the following is my new fav...
I present: NATALIE's EYE POP
Now, had I actually been smart enough to think ahead I would have saved the before pics to show you but I will provide you with this link instead.
And now you can try it yourselves!
Yes, I am biased but my boys have some of the most beautiful eyes I have ever seen
(even without a little 'pop').